Chapter 5 - THE PRE-TRIAL MANEUVERS
Z
The news of Victoria Vance’s attempted flight broke at 6:00 AM the following morning.
Armed with Julian’s signed confession and the key to the safety deposit box, Detective Ramirez and federal marshals intercepted Victoria at Logan International Airport as she attempted to board an international flight using a fraudulently obtained passport.
The lockbox inside First National Bank yielded a goldmine of criminal evidence: forged land deeds, illegal notary stamps from Donald Croft, and offshore account ledgers detailing the theft of $450,000 from my grandfather’s dying days.
With bail revoked, Victoria was remanded to the county correctional facility without bond, facing federal wire fraud, aggravated assault, grand larceny, and conspiracy charges.
Yet, despite her incarceration, Victoria refused to go down quietly.
Two weeks later, as I was undergoing physical therapy for my fractured wrist and ankle, Eleanor received a formal legal notice. Victoria had hired Arthur Vance-Smyth—a high-priced, cutthroat defense attorney famous for representing cartel money launderers and corrupt politicians.
Vance-Smyth filed a counter-suit against the Arthur Sterling Property Trust, launching a smear campaign in the press. He leaked fabricated medical records claiming I suffered from severe psychological instability, alleging that I had thrown myself down the basement stairs in a fit of rage to frame my mother-in-law after catching my husband in an affair.
The tabloid headlines were relentless: "STERLING HEIRESS STAGED BASEMENT FALL TO DESTROY IN-LAWS?"
“It’s a classic defense tactic,” Eleanor explained as we sat in her conference room preparing for a court-ordered deposition. “When the physical evidence is overwhelming, you attack the victim’s credibility. They want to create enough reasonable doubt in the public eye to force the prosecutor into offering a misdemeanor plea.”
“They’re claiming I was suicidal,” I said, gripping my crutch until my knuckles turned white. “They called my physical therapist trying to buy my progress notes.”
“They’re desperate,” Eleanor replied smoothly, opening her laptop. “And desperation leads to fatal mistakes. Look at what Donald Croft did yesterday.”
She clicked play on a recorded phone call provided by the FBI.
Donald Croft’s raspy voice came through the speakers: “Arthur, listen to me. Vance-Smyth says if we stick to the story that Nora was drunk and fell, the trust will settle for two hundred grand just to stop the press. You get your cut, I get mine.”
Vance-Smyth had crossed the line from defense strategy into suborning perjury and witness tampering.
An hour later, we entered the downtown courthouse for the preliminary deposition. The hallway was packed with news reporters and camera crews.
Victoria sat at the defense table dressed in a plain gray jail jumpsuit, her hair unstyled, looking twenty years older without her makeup and designer clothes. Next to her sat Vance-Smyth, a sleek man in a three-thousand-dollar suit, grinning as if he already owned the courtroom.
Julian was brought in separately, seated at the edge of the prosecution’s table, avoiding his mother’s glares.
“Mrs. Sterling,” Vance-Smyth began, stepping up to the podium with an obnoxious air of confidence. “We are here to record your sworn statement regarding the events of October 14th. Do you maintain that my client pushed you?”
“She drove both hands into my shoulders and threw me down fourteen wooden steps,” I stated clearly, looking Vance-Smyth dead in the eye.
Vance-Smyth smirked, pulling a stack of papers from his leather folder. “Is it not true, Mrs. Sterling, that you have a documented history of severe clinical depression? Is it not true that three days prior to this incident, you threatened your husband that you would 'destroy his life' if he proceeded with the divorce?”
“Objection,” Eleanor stated calmly. “Counsel is fabricating claims without medical foundation.”
“I’m establishing a pattern of vindictive behavior!” Vance-Smyth snapped, turning toward the court reporter. “The witness staged this entire ordeal because her husband dared to leave her!”
“Mr. Vance-Smyth,” I interrupted, keeping my voice level, steady, and loud enough for every microphone in the room to catch. “If I staged my fall, did I also stage the security camera mounted above my grandfather’s workbench?”
Vance-Smyth’s smirk faltered slightly. “The camera video is inconclusive—”
“Did I also stage the cloud transmission timestamp that proves Julian waited forty-seven minutes to call emergency services while you and Victoria searched my desk?” I continued, leaning forward. “Did I stage the $450,000 in wire transfers that your client forged using her cousin’s illegal notary stamp while my grandfather lay dying of dementia?”
Victoria suddenly slammed her hands on the table, standing up so fast her chair screeched against the floor.
“You liar!” she shrieked, her face twisting into a hideous mask of rage. “You worthless little brat! That money was ours! Arthur owed me! I gave twenty years of my life to that company and he left me with nothing! You deserved to rot at the bottom of those stairs!”
The courtroom erupted into total chaos.
Camera shutters clicked furiously. Vance-Smyth lunged forward, grabbing Victoria’s arm, trying to force her back into her seat. “Victoria, shut up! Shut your mouth!”
“I won't shut up!” Victoria screamed, wrestling against her attorney’s grip, her eyes wide and wild as she glared at me. “She thinks she won! She thinks she’s special because of her grandpa’s trust! I built that estate! I deserved that house!”
Judge Thomas slammed his gavel down repeatedly, his face thunderous. “Order! Order in this court! Bailiffs, restrain the defendant!”
Two armed bailiffs rushed forward, grabbing Victoria by the arms and forcing her down into her chair, snapping fresh restraints onto her wrists.
May you like
I sat calmly in my wheelchair, watching her pant and foam at the mouth like a cornered animal. Beside her, Vance-Smyth pinched the bridge of his nose, his sleek confidence completely shattered. He knew, just as everyone in that room knew, that Victoria had just confessed to the assault, the motive, and the fraud live on court record in front of twenty reporters.
Eleanor leaned over to me and whispered, “That, my dear Nora, is what we call a total defense collapse.”
